Jamaican Curry Goat
Bone-in goat seared in hot curry powder, then simmered down with Scotch bonnet, thyme and pimento until the meat slides off the bone and the gravy goes dark and glossy. Heat, funk and allspice-soaked depth: this is the pot that anchors a Jamaican Sunday table.
- Total
- 160 min
- Heat
- 4/5
- Serves
- 6
Sign in to see what you already have, what you can swap and what’s missing.
Flavour profile
- Peppery
- Rich
- Smoky
- Spicy
The real deal
- Region
- Jamaica, with the curry trail running from indentured Indian labourers in the nineteenth century to every Jamaican Sunday pot and roadside cookshop.
- Technique
- Burn the curry powder in hot oil first, then braise bone-in goat low and slow so the marrow thickens the gravy; finish with scorched Scotch bonnet, thyme and pimento.
- We kept
- Bone-in goat, blue-mountain-style Jamaican curry powder, Scotch bonnet heat, ground allspice, fresh thyme and coconut-milk-marinated base; no tomatoes, no cream, no softening of the chilli.
Ingredients
Braise
- 1.5 kg · bone-in shoulder or neck, cut into pieces (ask the butcher for curry-cut)
- 5 tbsp · Jamaican-style, ideally Blue Mountain
- 1 · whole, pierced; left whole so the gravy stays drinkable
- 3 tbsp
- 30 g
- 700 ml · or water
- 200 ml · full-fat, tinned
- 6 · peeled, cut into large chunks
- 4 · peeled, cut into batons
seasoning
- 1½ tsp · whole pimento berries
- 1 tsp
- 6 · fresh sprigs, tied
- 2 tsp
Aromatics
- 8 cloves
- 5 cm
- 2 · finely chopped
- 12 · sliced, white and green parts kept apart
finish
- 2
Method
Pat dry and rub it all over with 2 tsp , half the and the , crushed. Get the curry and salt into every cut and crease of the meat. Cover the seasoned goat and leave it for 30 min while you chop everything else. It will look dry and gritty; that is right, the salt is pulling moisture out of the meat.
Tip: Bone-in curry-cut goat is the point: the bones, marrow and connective tissue are what thicken the gravy.
Crush and chop and 5 cm into a rough paste with a pinch of salt. Chop 2 fine and slice 6 , keeping the green tops separate for the finish. Peel and cut 3 into large chunks and 2 into batons. Cut 1 into wedges and park them with the scallion greens.
Stab 1 once or twice with a knife tip and leave it whole. Whole, it perfumes the gravy; burst, it can blow the pot apart.
Tip: Never cut a Scotch bonnet open for this dish unless you want the whole pot screaming hot. Fish it out at the end.
Heat a heavy pot over medium heat and add 3 tbsp and 30 g . When the butter foams, add the rest of the — 3 tbsp — and stir it hard. It will spit, smoke and go a dark olive-brown in about 1 min. This is the step that gives Jamaican curry its colour and its deep, toasty backbone. Pull the pot off the heat the second it darkens; seconds later it goes bitter.
Tip: Burnt-but-not-black is the whole game: if it smells acrid rather than toasty, throw the oil out and start again.
Add the marinated goat to the burnt curry base and turn the heat to high heat. Sear it hard in a single layer — work in batches if your pot is small — until every piece is browned and crusted, about 8 min. It should hiss and stick a little; scrape up the fond as you go.
Push the goat to the sides and drop the onion, garlic, ginger and scallion whites into the middle with a pinch more salt. Fry until soft and sweet-smelling, about 3 min, then stir everything together.
Add 700 ml , the , the and the pierced . Scrape the bottom clean, bring to a bare simmer, then cover and cook low for 1 h 15 min, stirring every half hour and topping up with a splash of water if it threatens to dry.
Tip: Goat on the bone needs real time. If it is still chewy at ninety minutes, it is not done — give it another thirty.
After the first long simmer the meat should be yielding but not falling apart. Add the potato and carrot, plus the 200 ml , and simmer uncovered for another 20 min, until the potatoes are cooked through and the gravy has thickened and darkened to a deep mahogany.
Tip: The coconut milk goes in late so it does not split; stir it in gently and keep the heat low.
Fish out the Scotch bonnet and the thyme stems and taste. The gravy should be dark, glossy, hot and just slightly tart from the coconut milk. Squeeze in the lime wedges, scatter the scallion greens over the top and serve with rice and peas.
Tip: Do not salt before tasting — a hot pot like this tightens as it reduces, and the coconut milk already hides salt.
Make it a meal
What hits hardest next to it.
- Rice & noodlesStarchyRichCreamy
The gravy needs something to soak into and the rice-and-peas brings coconut richness that matches the curry's fat.
Try: Jamaican rice and peas with coconut milk and kidney beans
Nothing on the site fits yet. Ask the Lab to cook one up →
- SaladSourCrunchyCoolingFresh
A cold, sharp, cabbage-heavy crunch resets the palate between spoonfuls of heavy curry.
Try: Shaved cabbage and carrot slaw with lime, vinegar and a pinch of sugar
From our kitchen
Shirazi SaladTURKISH · TURKEY — 20 MIN
Lebanese Fattoush with SumacINDIAN · INDIA — 30 MIN
Vietnamese Green Mango Salad with Dried ShrimpVIETNAMESE · VIETNAM — 30 MIN
- SideStarchySweetCharred
Soft sweet plantain offsets the chilli heat and soaks up the last of the gravy.
Try: Ripe plantain pan-fried in hot oil until the edges caramelise
From our kitchen
Sichuan Dry-Fried Green Beans with PorkSICHUAN · CHINA — 30 MIN
Sambal Goreng TempehINDONESIAN · INDONESIA — 45 MIN
